diff --git a/plugins_src/plugin_aoc.go b/plugins_src/plugin_aoc.go
index 8de9eeb..aaf1b57 100644
--- a/plugins_src/plugin_aoc.go
+++ b/plugins_src/plugin_aoc.go
@@ -411,11 +411,13 @@ func (s *AoCState) AoCBoardCheckAndUpdate(yr int) {
 					plural = "stars"
 				}
 				mbrAll := s.getMemberAllYears(v.ID)
+				// Gather all stars from all leaderboards
 				var totalStars int
 				for _, v := range mbrAll {
 					totalStars += v.Stars
 				}
-				allYearsText := fmt.Sprintf(" (%d for all years)", totalStars+v.Stars)
+				// Add this new one into the total
+				allYearsText := fmt.Sprintf(" (%d for all years)", totalStars+1)
 				if yr == s.GetLatestYear() {
 					s.SendSlackMessage(fmt.Sprintf(":christmas_tree: %s now has %d %s! :christmas_tree:%s", v.Name, v.Stars, plural, allYearsText), channelId)
 				} else {